Baker Botts has announced that it successfully defended Gazprom against a claim for USD 1.37 billon lodged in the United States by Moncrief Oil International.
According to a statement released by Baker Botts, “the Fort Worth, Texas jury trial, which was in its fourth week of testimony presented to 14 jurors from the Fort Worth area, was suddenly dismissed with prejudice by Moncrief on Monday, February 2, 2015.” Lawyers from the Kelly Hart law firm in Ft. Worth, Texas, represented Moncrief Oil.
Moncrief was claiming that Gazprom backed out of a deal for rights to develop a natural gas field in Siberia, sabotaged the business agreement, and stole its trade secrets. According to BloombergBusiness, the case was dismissed upon the revelation that a key piece of evidence the U.S. company relied on was revealed to be fake, which Baker Botts Trial Partner Van Beckwith described as “stunning” and his personal “Perry Mason moment.” Gazprom has claimed in a January 29 filing with the court that Moncrief had “brazenly fabricated evidence and knowingly offered false testimony.”
Michael Calhoon, a Trial Partner with Baker Botts, declared it a “major victory for our client Gazprom.” According to Calhoon, “the dismissal of this case during trial puts an end to years of litigation by Moncrief Oil International over alleged trade secrets and supposed interference with its business, none of which had merit. It took a long time to get here, but this is the right result.”
Van Beckwith concurred, saying: “This was a difficult case from the start, which was tried in Moncrief’s hometown but we worked hard to share our side of the story with the dedicated and hard working women and men of the jury. The jury did a great job understanding the complexities of the global liquified natural gas business.”
This was the third attempt by Moncrief to litigate its claim against Gazprom. Earlier attempts in 2007 before a Texas federal court and in 2010 in Germany were both dismissed for lack of jurisdiction. “After years of litigation losses in federal court, Moncrief Oil decided their hometown state court offered the best opportunity for victory,” said Partner Michael Goldberg, another member of the Baker Botts team representing Gazprom. “I am proud of our trial team for not backing down and ultimately getting to the truth which resulted in this dismissal with prejudice.”
In addition to Calhoon, Beckwith, and Goldberg, other members of the Baker Botts team included Partnera Ryan Bangerts, Aaron Street, Macey Stokes, and Tom Phillips, Senior Associate John Lawrence, and Associates Eddie LaCour, Kristin Cope, Monica Hughes, Melissa Hurter, Chequan Lewis, Mark Little, and Russ Herman.
Image source: Merkushev Vasiliy / Shutterstock.com