Category: Russia

  • Andrey Gorodissky & Partners Advises Founders of “Kitchen on the District” Service on Sale to O2O

    Andrey Gorodissky & Partners has advised the founders of the “Kitchen in the District” service on their sale of an 87.4% stake in the company to O2O, a joint venture of the Mail.ru Group and Sberbank.

    The founders retain the remaining shares.

    Andrey Gorodissky & Partners’ team was led by Partner Alexey Gorodissky.

    Andrey Gorodissky & Partners did not reply to our inquiry on the matter.

    Editor’s note: After this article was published, Hogan Lovells announced that its Moscow office had advised O2O Holding on the deal. The firm’s team included Partner Oxana Balayan, Senior Counsel Maria Baeva, and Associates Olga Khachikyan, Anastasia Chapurina, and Denis Shakhov.

  • EPAM Successful for Ilya Averyanov in Murder Trial

    Egorov Puginsky Afanasiev & Partners has successfully defended Ilya Averyanov, the former owner of the Menshevik Confectionary in South-Eastern Moscow, in a trial involving charges that he murdered a guard at the factory.

    According to EPAM, “Averyanov was arrested two years ago on charges of murdering a guard.” The firm reports that its lawyers managed to “prove at the time that an attempted hostile takeover of Menshevik Confectionary was the true reason for the tragedy. As a result, Averyanov was found not guilty of murder by the Moscow City Court, a decision later confirmed by the Appellate court.” The case was finally brought before the Supreme Court of Russia, where, according to the firm, “the court dismissed the cassation appeal and upheld the acquittal of the defendant.” 

    The Egorov Puginsky Afanasiev & Partners team included Partner Victoria Burkovskaya, Counsel Andrey Bastrakov, and Associates Maria Zazirnaya and Anton Lubimov.

  • Baker McKenzie Helps Russia’s PJSC Koks with Eurobond Issuance

    Baker McKenzie has advised PJSC Koks on the issuance of new Eurobonds by subsidiary IMH Capital and a cash tender offer together with an exit consent solicitation to the holders of USD 500 million notes due 2022 issued by Koks Finance, another subsidiary of PJSC Koks.

    The joint lead managers involved in the transaction were Citi, Renaissance Capital, Alfa Bank, Gazprombank, Sber CIB, VTB Capital, and Sova Capital.

    According to Baker McKenzie, “[IMH Capital’s] offering consists of USD 350 million in notes, with annual interest rate of 5.90% notes, which are due 2025 and are registered in the Rule 144A / Reg S format. The new notes were listed on the Global Exchange Market of the Irish Stock Exchange.”

    PJSC Koks is a Russia-based company that was founded in 1924 and which is primarily involved in the production and distribution of coke and coal concentrate, iron ore concentrate, and pig iron.

    Baker McKenzie’s team included, in Moscow, Partner Dmitry Dembich and Associates Adil Guseynov and Polina Govkelevich, and in London, Partners Roy Pearce and Megan Schellinger, Counsel Charles Farnsworth, Senior Associate Maxim Khrapov, and Associate Andrew Brown.

    Baker McKenzie did not reply to an inquiry about the deal.

  • Alexey Statsenko Makes Partner at EY in Moscow

    Alexey Statsenko, the Regional General Counsel for Central, Eastern and Southeastern Europe & Central Asia at EY, has been promoted to equity partner at EY.

    Based in Moscow, Statsenko leads a 50-strong team of legal professionals supporting EY member firms’ business in the region that comprises almost nearly sixty offices and more than 14,000 people in almost thirty countries.

    Statsenko has been with EY since September 2009, when he joined the Big 4 company as the General Counsel for Russia & CIS. He took on the regional GC role in July 2018 (as reported by CEE Legal Matters on July 4, 2018). Prior to EY, Statsenko was the Legal & External Affairs Director for Russia & CIS at Nissan Motor Co. Earlier still, he served as the Legal Manager for Russia & CIS at Fonterra. 

    Commenting on his promotion, Statsenko told CEEIHM: “It’s a great honor for me to be admitted to the EY partnership, and I am especially thrilled to become an EY Partner in this turbulent times. I am grateful to my leadership and my fellow partners for their trust and recognition of the role our Legal function plays, helping our teams serve the clients at this challenging moment and doing our part in building a better working world.”

    Originally reported by CEE In-House Matters.

  • White & Case and Hogan Lovells Advise on Mail.ru’s Equity Placement and Convertible Bond Offering

    White & Case has advised sole global coordinator and bookrunner Morgan Stanley & Co International on Mail.ru’s US 200 million equity placing and further US 400 million convertible bonds offering due in 2025. Hogan Lovells provided legal advisory services to Mail.ru.

    Mail.ru is a Russian-based Internet access provider, online games developer, and operator of social networking websites, instant messaging networks, and email services.

    White & Case’s team in London consisted of Partners Darina Lozovsky, Inigo Esteve, and Richard Pogrel, and Associates Andrew Scott, Neha Saran, and Hashim Eltumi.

    The Hogan Lovells team included, in London, Partners Dan Simons, Raj Panasar, Jonathan Baird, Aline Doussin, Oxana Balayan, and Kieron O’Callaghan, Senior Associates Daria Latysheva and Imogen Brooks, and Associates Taylor Harris and Scott Prior; and Washington, Partner Aleksander Dukic.

  • Kachkin & Partners Successful for STEP in Dispute against Pharmasintez-Nord

    Kachkin & Partners has successfully helped Russian general contractor STEP LLC reach a settlement with Pharmasintez-Nord JSC in a dispute regarding payment for work and related claims worth over RUR 100 million.

    According to Kachkin & Partners, Pharmasintez-Nord had ordered the construction of a research-and-manufacturing complex for medicine development and production in St. Petersburg. According to the firm, “the dispute between the parties was accompanied by unsigned acts of acceptance of the work results, a dispute on the quality of the performed work, presence of additional work, and a dispute on meeting the deadlines and quality of the original documentation provided by the customer. In addition, it was complicated by a significant amount of documentation and the rapid progressing of operations on the construction site.”

    Kachkin & Partners’ team included Partner Dmitry Nekrestyanov and Associate Lyudmila Stepanova.

  • Dmitriy Chepurenko Becomes Managing Partner at Liniya Prava

    Dmitriy Chepurenko, the Head of Dispute Resolution and White-Collar Crime and Business Defense at Liniya Prava, has become the Russian firm’s new Managing Partner.

    Chepurenko joined Liniya Prava in 2008 as Head of Dispute Resolution and Insolvency. He made Partner at the firm in 2010.

    Liniya Prava describes Chepurenko as a “well-recognized expert in procedural law who has exceptional skills and broad experience in representing the clients in civil and arbitration courts.” According to the firm, “the Liniya Prava team is confident that under Dmitriy’s leadership the firm will continue to grow, develop, and provide high-profile services.”

  • Deal 5: Norilsk Nickel’s Andrey Gavrikov on USD 500 Million Eurobond Offering

    On September 15, 2020, CEE Legal Matters reported that Debevoise & Plimpton had advised Norilsk Nickel on its USD 500 million Eurobond offering due 2025. CEEIHM spoke with Andrey Gavrikov, Head of Direction for Legal Support of Treasury Operations at MMC Norilsk Nickel, to learn more about the issuance.

    CEEIHM: Please share a few words about Norilsk Nickel and its operations in Russia for our readers. 

    Andrey: Nornickel is Russia’s leading metals and mining company, the number one manufacturer of palladium and refined nickel, and one of the biggest platinum and copper producers. The group also produces cobalt, rhodium, silver, gold, iridium, ruthenium, selenium, tellurium, and sulfur. The products are supplied to over 30 countries. In addition to its production facilities, the company has its own sales network, fuel and energy companies, transport assets, a body of R&D units, and a unique Arctic cargo fleet. The company’s securities are among the most liquid instruments in domestic and foreign equity markets. In Russia, the shares of MMC Norilsk Nickel are on the First Level quotation list of the Moscow Exchange and admitted to trading at the Saint-Petersburg Exchange. Its ADRs are traded on the US OTC market and in the electronic trading system of OTC markets at the London, Berlin, and Frankfurt stock exchanges. The company’s ADRs are also included in the FTSE Russia IOB Index of the London Stock Exchange.

    CEEIHM: What is the capital raised through this Eurobond intended for?

    Andrey: The company traditionally uses the capital from Eurobonds for general corporate purposes, including capital investments and the refinancing of its debt portfolio. The current issue has become a record for Russia and CIS – the transaction resulted in the lowest coupon ever achieved by a corporate or sovereign issuer out of Russia and CIS for any USD-denominated Eurobond public placement – which gives us a degree of flexibility for the further use of the funds we received. 

    CEEIHM: CEE Legal Matters reported on several similar issuances over the years. How would you say your in-house systems have improved over the years to deal with this type of recurring work? 

    Andrey: The Nornickel group employs about 80,000 people in total. At the same time, the group’s business is quite diverse – we have our own aircraft fleet, helicopters, Arctic icebreaking fleet, and various social and infrastructure facilities, all in addition to our production line. The assets are located in regions from Australia to the United States, from Africa to the Arctic circle. These all make the task of conducting due diligence, collecting the necessary information, and sifting out unnecessary data quite challenging. The Eurobond Prospectus preparation is always about working with people and with a large amount of data. Despite this difficult task, we have learned to enter the bond market within a very tight timeframe. The average period of preparation for release takes one month from the moment of a decision to initiate the process until its public placement. In fact, that one month is the minimum possible time under the market procedures. The current release was a record not only for the result achieved but also for the conditions under which the release was made. I am referring here to the COVID-19 outbreak, remote working of employees, and the general world situation. Behind the successful placement lies the professionalism of the team and, definitely, the well-coordinated interaction of the whole team involved. 

    CEEIHM: What would you point to as the most complex aspect of the offering from a legal standpoint? 

    Andrey: The most complex aspects relate mainly to the work within the organization; management and coordination and in some part educational work with production, technical ecological, and other departments and the interaction with local business units. Imagine that within a couple of weeks you need to turn an 80,000-employee organization upside-down with investigations and detection of all the necessary information and then translate that into legal language for the placement. Documentation for the placement is also an important part of the process, but in our case, it has already been worked out for years in the framework of previous issues, plus additional assistance is provided by the banks involved in the issue and by legal consultants (both from our side and the banks’ side). 

    CEEIHM: Debevoise previously advised Norilsk Nickel on a number of similar finance and capital market matters, including on six previous Eurobond offerings totaling USD 5 billion. How was that relationship initiated and why do you continue to turn to the firm for legal assistance on these kinds of matters?

    Andrey: The fundamental principle is the high quality of work and professionalism. However, this is not all. There are a number of top-level law firms in Moscow and we can say that a high level of professionalism is the must for them to be engaged in any Nornickel business. For Debevoise the key order winners are basically two: (1) a deep understanding of the company’s business model and market situation; (2) the firm provides more than just legal support, it helps in developing a general strategy of the whole process, provides a “business view” and has a common transaction-oriented approach, rather than purely a “legislative” one. All these together allow the whole team to achieve high results in our activities.

    Originally reported by CEE In-House Matters.

  • Procedure Amended for Determining Whether a Foreign Investor Controls a Russian Strategic Company

    To prevent foreign investors from abusing their rights in relation to Russian strategic companies, the prior-clearance rules have changed to qualify transactions for a stake in this type of company. The change was made to protect strategic companies from undisclosed foreign interference and has resulted in a more transparent foreign investment environment in Russia.

    In August 2020, amendments* came into force for Federal Law No. 57-FZ “On the Procedure for Making Foreign Investments in Commercial Companies of Strategic Importance for Ensuring the Defence of the Country and the Security of the State”.

    These amendments clarify the procedure for determining a foreign investor’s control of a Russian strategic company through its shares (in joint-stock companies) or participatory interests (in limited liability companies). For the sake of simplicity, this article describes shares only, but the same rules apply to participatory interests.

    As a result, shares for which a foreign investor does not actually dispose of voting rights, including if they are temporarily transferred to a third party (e.g. under a property trust agreement, pledge agreement, repo agreement, security deposit), must now be taken into account to determine the threshold values under which a foreign investor controls a strategic company.

    By way of background, Federal Law No. 57-FZ sets various thresholds for determining whether a foreign investor controls a Russian strategic company (for more details, please refer to the relevant section of our “Doing business in Russia” guide). The main thresholds include the following:

      • when an investor directly or indirectly disposes of more than 50% of the total number of votes attributable to voting shares of a Russian strategic company; and
    • when an investor directly or indirectly disposes of 25% or more of the total number of votes attributable to voting shares of a Russian strategic company that uses a subsoil plot of federal significance.

    Previously, foreign investors could, in fact, transfer their rights to dispose of voting shares of a strategic company to a third party without taking these shares into account when determining whether they control a strategic company. As a result, in certain cases, foreign investors could avoid clearing transactions of a strategic company’s shares with the Government Commission for the Control of Foreign Investment in the Russian Federation.

    In fact, the amendments deprive foreign investors of the ability to exempt themselves from having their transactions cleared with the Government Commission in the above cases.

    Taking into account that concluding transactions in violation of legal regulatory-clearance requirements makes these transactions null and void, it is vital for foreign investors acquiring stakes in Russian strategic companies to take into account the amendments when structuring their transactions.

    In Russian

    By Maxim Boulba, Partner, and Elena Andrianova, Senior Associate, CMS Russia

  • Eversheds Sutherland Advises the Cherkizovo Group on Acquisition of Cargill Facility in Russia

    Eversheds Sutherland has advised the Cherkizovo Group on its acquisition of Compas Foods LLC, a chicken processing facility in the Tula region of Russia that is a subsidiary of Cargill Inc. Tomashevskaya & Partners reportedly advised Cargill on the transaction.

    According to Eversheds Sutherland, “the Cherkizovo Group is the largest vertically integrated meat producer in Russia. This acquisition will help to expand Cherkizovo’s presence among clients in the food service sector.”

    Eversheds Sutherland’s team was led by Managing Partner Victoria Goldman and Partner Mikhail Timonov and included by Counsel Anton Bakov and Senior Associate Leyla Ibragimova.