Category: Poland

  • Jara Drapala & Partners Successful for Porr in Dispute Against General Directorate for National Roads and Motorways

    Jara Drapala & Partners Successful for Porr in Dispute Against General Directorate for National Roads and Motorways

    Jara Drapala & Partners has obtained a judgement on behalf of Porr S.A. awarding it over PLN 11 million against Poland’s General Directorate for National Roads and Motorways for performance of works exceeding the contract scope.

    JD&P describes Porr S.A. as “one of the leading contractors of roads and bridges.” According to the firm, “the dispute regarded the construction of one of the expressways executed on the ‘construct’ basis …. Based on the evidence submitted by the contractor’s representatives the Regional Court in Warsaw declared that the description of the scope of the works to be performed was incomprehensible and unclear, the technical specifications contained contradictory data, and the design documentation provided by the investor did not contain all necessary elements. The obligation to discover such defects and contradictions does not lie with the contractor. The Court agreed with the arguments of the JD&P lawyers and declared that … a portion of the performed work … exceeded the contractor’s contractual obligation and hence the claim for reimbursement of the cost of these works was to be allowed.”

    In JD&P’s opinion, “this judgement may substantially influence the court practice in regard to pursuing by contractors claims for reimbursement of costs of additional works incurred due to faults, defects and internal contradictions in the design documentation and specifications (in particular contracts based on a lump sum) as well as the method for calculating the amount of such claims.”

    The judgement is not final.

    The JD&P team was led by Partner Przemyslaw Drapala and included Partner Andrzej Sokolowski and Legal Advisor Filip Rasala.

    Editor’s Note: On October 6, 2017, CEE Legal Matters was informed by Jara Drapala & Partners that Porr S.A. had reached an agreement with the General Directorate for National Roads and Motorways under which Porr was paid PLN 12 million. According to JD&P, “as part of the settlement, a number of claims of the general contractor have been settled, including claims for remuneration for substitute works, costs incurred within the extended Completion Period, overall costs of the construction office, costs of adjustment to general requirements, as well as damages …. Thanks to the success in court of first instance and further involvement of JD&P, the contractor received the payments it was entitled to without the need to conduct further proceedings.”

  • Clifford Chance and A&O Advise on EIB Agreements with Energa Regarding Hybrid Bond Issuance

    Clifford Chance and A&O Advise on EIB Agreements with Energa Regarding Hybrid Bond Issuance

    Clifford Chance has advised the European Investment Bank on its September 4, 2017 entrance into a project agreement and a subscription agreement with Energa S.A. providing the basis for the issue of EUR 250 million hybrid bonds. Allen & Overy advised Energa on the deal.

    According to Clifford Chance, “the purpose of the financing is the implementation of the investment program in the energy distribution segment, including modernization and expansion of the distribution assets of the Energa Group in 2017-2019. The bonds are unsubordinated, unsecured, coupon bearer securities, which will be subscribed for by the EIB as part of the European Fund for Strategic Investments initiative, launched by the EIB jointly with the European Commission for the purpose of implementing the so-called Juncker Plan. The bonds will be issued in two tranches with a total nominal value of: (i) EUR 125 million, with a 16-year maturity and with the first financing period defined at six years from the issue date; and (ii) EUR 125 million, with a 20-year maturity and with the first financing period defined at 10 years from the issue date.”

    The Clifford Chance team was supervised and co-ordinated by Warsaw Managing Partner Grzegorz Namiotkiewicz, supported by Warsaw-based Counsel Grzegorz Abram and Associate Pawel Zagorski. Several lawyers from Clifford Chance’s London office worked on the matter as well, including Partners Paul Deakins and Clare Burgess and Associate Halim Uddin.

    The Allen & Overy team was led by Partner Piotr Lesinski.

  • Hogan Lovells and Allen & Overy Advise the Nordea Group on Nordea OFE Merger with Aegon PTE

    Hogan Lovells and Allen & Overy Advise the Nordea Group on Nordea OFE Merger with Aegon PTE

    Hogan Lovells has advised the Nordea Group on transferring the managing capabilities from Nordea OFE to Aegon PTE. Allen & Overy advised Aegon PTE on the transaction, which was finalized on September 1, 2017. Financial details were not disclosed.

    According to Hogan Lovells, the merger of Nordea OFE and Aegon OFE will result in the fourth largest pension fund on the market in terms of membership and asset value.

    The Hogan Lovells Warsaw team supervised and coordinated by Managing Partner Beata Balas-Noszczyk included Partner Andrzej Debiec, Counsels Tomasz Zak and Dorota Walerjan, Lawyer Michal Bialobrzeski, Senior Associate Agnieszka Szczodra-Hajduk, and Associates Mateusz Mazurkiewicz, Karol Ruszkowski, and Joanna Fiema-Kurek.

    The Allen & Overy team consisted of Partner Jaroslaw Iwanicki, Senior Associates Tomasz Ciecwierz and Maciek Kulawik, and Associate Joanna Kaleta.

  • CMS and Noerr Advise on the Sale of Delicpol to Continental Bakeries

    CMS and Noerr Advise on the Sale of Delicpol to Continental Bakeries

    CMS has advised private equity fund Resource Partners, a longstanding client of the firm, on its sale of Delicpol, a manufacturer of cookies sold under private labels, to Continental Bakeries, a manufacturer of sweets owned by Goldman Sachs Merchant Baking Division and Silverfern, a private equity fund. Noerr Warsaw advised the buyers on the deal. Closing of the transaction is contingent on the approval of market regulators.

    “The transaction may be one of the largest transactions carried out on the Polish foodstuffs market this year,” claims CMS Partner Marek Sawicki, who led his firm’s team on the deal. “The food sector has been undergoing consolidation and we may expect further ownership changes in the near future.” Sawicki was supported by Senior Associate Izabela Gebal.

    Noerr Partners Jakub Lerner and Ludomir Biedecki led the firm’s team representing Continental Bakeries. Additional team members included Rafal Kozlowski, Marta Smolarz, Mateusz Slodczyk, Tomasz Garncarek, and Wojciech Nowosad.

  • DZP Advises Polish Broadcaster TVN on Sale of Mango Media

    DZP Advises Polish Broadcaster TVN on Sale of Mango Media

    DZP has advised the Polish broadcaster TVN on the sale of 100% of shares of Mango-Media sp. z o.o. to Studio Moderna Polska sp. z o.o.

    Mango-Media specializes in telemarketing and the online sales of goods.

    According to DZP, “the sale was concluded after months of negotiations between the two parties. The deal included deferred payment structure, agreements on cooperation between the target (comparatively new company) and seller’s group following the completion, non-competition and non-solicitation legal matters. The sale will allow the broadcaster, which is owned by Scripps Networks Interactive, to consolidate its portfolio and focus on the development of its core business.”

    The DZP team was led by Partner Magdalena Skowronska, supported by Maciej Zajda and Katarzyna Biarda.

  • CMS Promotes Anna Cudna-Wagner to Partner

    CMS Promotes Anna Cudna-Wagner to Partner

    Anna Cudna-Wagner has been promoted to Partner at CMS in Poland.

    According to CMS, Cudna-Wagner is “responsible primarily for acting for clients from the banking sector in commercial and civil disputes before state courts and arbitration tribunals.” The firm reports that she “also specializes in court proceedings concerning Competition Law. Therefore, she will also coordinate this area of the firm’s dispute resolution practice and cooperate with our Competition Group led by Malgorzata Urbanska.”

    Before joining CMS in May 2017, Cudna-Wagner worked for over four years at Linklaters.

    CMS reports that, along with Anna Cudna-Wagner, advocate Bartosz Miaskiewicz has joined the CMS dispute resolution team, also from Linklaters.

  • Bird & Bird Advises mBank on Financing for Construction of Photovoltaic Projects Carried Out by Wento SPV

    Bird & Bird Advises mBank on Financing for Construction of Photovoltaic Projects Carried Out by Wento SPV

    Bird & Bird’s Warsaw office has advised mBank in a financing transaction for the construction of photovoltaic projects carried out by a special purpose entity from the Wento capital group.

    According to Bird & Bird, “the projects won the renewable energy auctions conducted in December 2016 and as such were guaranteed to be reimbursed for the so-called negative balance provided for in the Renewable Energy Act. The loan granted amounts of several tens of millions of Polish Zloty.”

    Bird & Bird’s team included Counsel Andrzej Nentwig, who described it as “a great pleasure to be able to advise on one of the first financing transactions in Poland related to a portfolio of commercial photovoltaic projects covered by the new support system for renewable energy sources.” 

    Nentwig was joined on Bird & Bird’s project team by Associate Lukasz Petelski, Head of Financing Transactions Maciej Georg, and Associate Anna Fujak.

    Jakub Gorzelnik, Head of Legal Department at Wento, led his company’s legal team on the deal. He described the company as “pleased that the completion of the transaction took place so efficiently,” which he says “was an important element of our strategy of developing a portfolio of photovoltaic projects.” 

  • Crido Legal Takes New Head of Real Estate from Dentons in Warsaw

    Crido Legal Takes New Head of Real Estate from Dentons in Warsaw

    Polish lawyer Krzysztof Marzynski has left Dentons to join Crido Legal as Partner and head of the firm’s Real Estate practice.

    According to Crido Legal, Marzynski “specializes in real estate and construction law as well as broadly construed commercial law. For over 13 years of his professional career, he has built up extensive experience, advising domestic and international clients on various legal matters, including sale, acquisition, leasing, management, financing and restructuring of commercial real estate, as well as so-called alternative assets, e.g., agricultural and forest real estate, residential premises for lease.”

    Prior to joining Crido Legal, Krzysztof worked for seven years at Dentons in Warsaw, and before that another three at Clifford Chance. 

    “From its very inception, Crido Legal has been continuously expanding its competences in respect of real estate and construction law and we have a proven track record of successful real estate projects,” said Jakub Ziolek, Managing Partner of Crido Legal. “With a new, extremely experienced Partner onboard we hope to strengthen and grow this practice. Our vision of expansion is even more feasible, as we sustain the synergy of our legal professionals and Crido’s tax advisors, who have been known for being involved in and delivering one of the biggest real estate deals in Poland.”

  • Important Changes to Polish Labor Law

    On January 1, 2017, a number of new provisions in Polish labor law came into force introducing some sig-nificant changes for employers and employees and, to a certain degree, for persons hired on the basis of contracts for work and service contracts. 

    The first two amendments were introduced by the Act Amending Certain Acts to Improve the Legal Envi-ronment for Enterprises of December 16, 2016 and were adopted in order to simplify various aspects of labor law.

    One of these two amendments relaxes some of the requirements for small businesses in connection with obligations to establish internal rules and social benefit funds. New legislation provides that companies with at least 50 employees not covered by a collective labor agreement must draw up remuneration regula-tions, and companies with between 20-50 employees that are not covered by a collective labor agreement must also draw up remuneration regulations if they are requested to do so by a workplace trade union. Sim-ilar obligations have been adopted for preparing workplace rules and for establishing a company social ben-efit fund. Until December 31, 2016, the obligation to establish internal policies and, with some exceptions, social benefit funds also applied to all companies with an employee headcount of at least 20 employees as of January 1 of each year.

    The second simplification concerns the issuance of employment certificates. According to the amendment effective from January 1, 2017, employers are now obliged to issue a work certificate containing specific details of the employment within seven days of termination of an employment contract, unless they intend to conclude a new employment contract with the employee – or even in those circumstances if the employ-ee so requests. This request may be delivered in electronic form. This change restores provisions which were valid before March 21, 2011.

    Another amendment in the Labor Code, this time of particular significance for employees, provides a new, unified time limit for filing appeals to the labor courts. It extends the deadlines for employees to appeal against a notice of dismissal or termination of employment without notice to 21 days from the delivery of the relevant letter of termination of an employment contract (with or without notice period), or from the date of expiry of an employment contract. The previous law provided two different terms – seven days to appeal against notice of dismissal and 14 days for claims concerning termination for cause and for establish-ing an employment relationship. 

    The amended Labor Code also changes the provisions on concluding agreements on shared financial liability of employees for entrusted property. According to the new rules, such agreements will be invalid unless they are in writing and signed by both the employer and the employee. Under the interim provisions, agreements which were concluded before January 1, 2017 will be governed by the old rules. 

    The last (but not least) important piece of legislation that came into effect on January 1, 2017 extended the coverage of the Minimum Wage Act, with several exceptions, to contractors and persons providing services to enterprises as part of their business activities. As of this date, they are entitled to a minimum rate of PLN 13 per hour (approximately EUR 3 per hour) in 2017 for performing an assignment or providing services.

    New legislation provides that it is not possible to waive or transfer the right to remuneration at the mini-mum rate to another person. The amendment also requires that a record be kept of the hours spent per-forming an assignment or providing services and that appropriate associated documentation should be kept for three years from the date on which the remuneration is due.

    The legislation described above provides a number of exceptions to the minimum hourly wage legislation. The most important relates to situations where the contractor or service-provider decides the time and place the assignment or services will be performed or offered and is entitled to remuneration only in the form of commission. The Act also provides that the minimum remuneration must be paid out in cash and, if the contract was concluded for a period longer than one month, that remuneration must be paid at least once a month.

    In view of this new legislation, provisions in contracts for work and service contracts concerning remunera-tion should be reviewed and adjusted (either by concluding new contracts or by amending existing ones). A breach of this obligation may result in a fine of PLN 1,000 to PLN 30,000.

    It should be also noted that on January 1, 2017 the minimum gross monthly wage for employees was raised, so that in 2017 it amounts to PLN 2,000 (approximately EUR 474).

    By Radoslaw Biedecki, Managing Partner, and Katarzyna Zwierz-Wilkocka, Senior Associate, Noerr Poland

    This Article was originally published in Issue 4.6 of the CEE Legal Matters Magazine. If you would like to receive a hard copy of the magazine, you can subscribe here.

  • Greenberg Traurig Takes Large Real Estate Team from Hogan Lovells in Poland

    Greenberg Traurig Takes Large Real Estate Team from Hogan Lovells in Poland

    The Warsaw office of Greenberg Traurig has added 11 members to its real estate practice in the persons of Partners Jolanta Nowakowska-Zimoch and Agata Jurek-Zbrojska, who move over from Hogan Lovells, bringing with them Local Partners Malgorzata Madej-Balcerowska and Justyna Szwech and seven Associates.

    Nowakowska-Zimoch, who was the head of Hogan Lovells’ Real Estate practice in Poland, takes over the now over 40-lawyer strong Greenberg Traurig practice. According to Greenberg Traurig, Nowakowska-Zimoch “brings more than 30 years of legal experience in real estate, focusing her practice on real estate transactions and financing of real estate projects. She has extensive experience in major transactions concerning commercial, office, and logistic properties and cross-border transactions. Her experience also includes arbitration proceedings in Poland.”   

    “I have been observing with great interest the development of Greenberg Traurig’s Real Estate Practice for the past two years and I know it will be a tremendously exciting experience to be a member of this team,” Nowakowska-Zimoch said.

    “Adding this team to our already robust and top-rate practice is a tremendous win for us and for our clients who require a firm with a dynamic real estate presence,” added Lejb Fogelman, the Warsaw office’s Senior Partner.