AstapovLawyers and Baker & McKenzie have successfully represented Canon Russia in a dispute with a Russian retailer Fotosintez involving claims of abuse of rights in a surety agreement.
Under a supply contract, the Russian subsidiary of the Japanese optical products corporation was to supply goods on a deferred payment basis. In August 2013, Fotosintez went bankrupt, with debt in the amount of more than RUB 200 million (equivalent to approximately USD 5.4 million). At the time, Fotointez’s majority shareholder claimed the surety agreement was invalid as in violation of corporate regulations.
In the first case reviewed by the recently created Judicial Chamber on Economic Disputes of the Supreme Court of Russian Federation, AstapovLawyers team supported Canon Russia in both the surety agreement invalidity case and the Fotosintez bankruptcy proceedings. The firm established that the majority shareholder alleging the surety agreement’s invalidity had in fact abused Canon Russia’s rights, and persuaded the Judicial Chamber to enforce the supply contract, in the process proving that the shareholder owning 50% of shares both in a buyer-company and surety-company has no right to claim invalidation of surety on the ground that he was unaware of the surety agreement and had never given his consent.
The case was handled by AstapovLawyers Senior Associate Andrey Samoilov and Associate Anna Arutunian. Baker & McKenzie Partner Vladimir Khvalei acted as co-counsel.